Most Valuable HeartGold & SoulSilver Cards — Top 25 (Market Value)

This is the live market-value ranking of every chase card in HeartGold & SoulSilver (2010), the 124-card Pokémon TCG expansion. Prices update on each PackRip build from TCGPlayer's market feed, so these numbers track the actual ungraded market rather than retail asks. The top 25 alone account for roughly $1741 in combined market value — that's where the pack-opening EV comes from.

Top 25 by TCGPlayer market price

1. #1. Lugia LEGEND — LEGEND, #114 — $261.51 (1 in 72 per pack)
2. #2. Lugia LEGEND — LEGEND, #113 — $231.66 (1 in 72 per pack)
3. #3. Ho-Oh LEGEND — LEGEND, #111 — $188.31 (1 in 72 per pack)
4. #4. Gyarados — Rare Holo, #123 — $127.02 (1 in 50 per pack)
5. #5. Alph Lithograph — Secret Rare, #ONE — $104.12 (1 in 20 per pack)
6. #6. Ho-Oh LEGEND — LEGEND, #112 — $92.98 (1 in 72 per pack)
7. #7. Feraligatr — Rare Prime, #108 — $81.66 (1 in 54 per pack)
8. #8. Typhlosion — Rare Prime, #110 — $60.30 (1 in 54 per pack)
9. #9. Arcanine — Rare Holo, #1 — $59.21 (1 in 50 per pack)
10. #10. Ampharos — Rare Prime, #105 — $57.76 (1 in 54 per pack)
11. #11. Gyarados — Rare Holo, #4 — $55.79 (1 in 50 per pack)
12. #12. Darkness Energy — Common, #121 — $54.19 (10.0% per pack)
13. #13. Meganium — Rare Prime, #109 — $49.44 (1 in 54 per pack)
14. #14. Psychic Energy — Common, #119 — $44.44 (10.0% per pack)
15. #15. Blissey — Rare Prime, #106 — $35.94 (1 in 54 per pack)
16. #16. Ninetales — Rare Holo, #7 — $31.33 (1 in 50 per pack)
17. #17. Donphan — Rare Prime, #107 — $27.57 (1 in 54 per pack)
18. #18. Water Energy — Common, #117 — $25.04 (10.0% per pack)
19. #19. Fire Energy — Common, #116 — $24.99 (10.0% per pack)
20. #20. Raichu — Rare Holo, #10 — $23.91 (1 in 50 per pack)
21. #21. Grass Energy — Common, #115 — $23.23 (10.0% per pack)
22. #22. Metal Energy — Common, #122 — $21.15 (10.0% per pack)
23. #23. Shuckle — Rare Holo, #11 — $21.14 (1 in 50 per pack)
24. #24. Lightning Energy — Common, #118 — $19.08 (10.0% per pack)
25. #25. Quagsire — Rare Holo, #9 — $18.98 (1 in 50 per pack)

How to pull the top card

The single most valuable card in HeartGold & SoulSilver is Lugia LEGEND at $261.51. You can chase it for free on PackRip's HeartGold & SoulSilver pack opener — it uses authentic per-rarity pull rates so the simulation produces the same expected-value distribution real boxes do over thousands of openings. The Hunt Pack mode boosts the relevant rarity slot if you want to optimize for this card specifically. Or skip the RNG and buy Lugia LEGEND directly on TCGplayer.

Why these prices change

2010 cards trade on relative supply: PSA pop reports, sealed-product scarcity, character popularity (especially Eeveelutions, starters, and legendary Pokémon), and grading-grade availability. PackRip refreshes its catalog every Phase release, so each new set drop pulls a fresh price snapshot via build-prices.mjs and the rankings reshuffle automatically. Bookmark this page — it stays current.

Why card #1 is worth multiples of card #25

The variance inside a single set's top-25 is itself the most informative number on this page. Lugia LEGEND at $261.51 sits roughly 13.8× the value of the #25 card ($18.98) — and that spread is the rule, not the exception, for 2010 HeartGold & SoulSilver. The driver is a compounding stack: rarity tier (a Holo Rare is a 1-in-3 pull, a Crystal / Gold Star / Lv.X / Prime / Full Art chase is 1-in-30+), character popularity (Charizard / Pikachu / Eeveelutions trade at multi-x the average for the same rarity tier), illustration quality (full-art and alt-art prints command premiums regardless of competitive viability), and PSA pop-report scarcity (PSA-10 populations for 2010 cards are still expanding, so a low pop today can be 10× the future pop in two years). The top-25 sorts by the joint product of all four, which is why the curve is so steep at the top and flattens by #20+ where the cards are usually Holo Rares of less-popular Pokémon.

Raw vs graded — the multiplier nobody tells beginners

Every price on this page is the raw ungraded NM/M TCGPlayer market median. Graded copies trade at a multiplier on top of that depending on the assigned grade and the population of that grade for the card. The conservative rule of thumb (cross-checked against PSA's own auction history): PSA 9 ≈ 2-3× raw, PSA 10 ≈ 5-10× raw for DP-era cards, with the chase tier (Crystal / Gold Star / Shining / Prime / LEGEND / Full Art) skewing higher because the absolute population is smaller. So Lugia LEGEND at a raw $261.51 typically prices a PSA 9 at $654-785 and a PSA 10 at $1308-2615. BGS 9.5 sits between PSA 9 and PSA 10. The grading-cost economics only work when the raw card is worth roughly 4× the grading fee — for 2010 HeartGold & SoulSilver that threshold is met by roughly the top 8 cards on this list.

Historical price trend — how the HeartGold & SoulSilver chase market evolved

The current $261.51 TCGplayer market price on Lugia LEGEND is the end-state of a multi-year re-rating. DP-era chases lagged the broader nostalgia boom by an additional 18 months — most of the re-rating happened in 2022-2023. Lv.X cards (including HeartGold & SoulSilver top chases) re-rated 3-10× depending on the specific card. The market is more rational here than at the WotC layer because supply is higher and the cohort is younger. Pricing data on PackRip refreshes monthly via the TCGplayer market feed and the snapshot date is visible at the bottom of every card detail page.

Set-specific drivers — why HeartGold & SoulSilver's top-25 looks the way it does

HeartGold & SoulSilver (2010) sits in a specific niche within the Pokémon TCG market that shapes which cards land in this top-25 and why. DP/Platinum-era sets are valued primarily on Lv.X chases plus a small handful of full-art and Secret Rare standouts. The market is less mature here than WotC or EX, which means individual chase cards can have wider bid-ask spreads. Within HeartGold & SoulSilver specifically, the top-25 reflects this set's particular blend of those factors — high-popularity characters in the chase tier rank disproportionately well, and the deeper into the list you go, the more the ranking reflects pure rarity over character pull.

Condition grading deep-dive — the PSA 10 multiplier

The single biggest determinant of price for any vintage Pokémon card is grading status. PSA 10 ("Gem Mint") copies for 2010 HeartGold & SoulSilver cards trade at substantial multiples of raw NM/M. The exact multiple depends on the specific card's pop report — common cards with high PSA 10 populations carry small premiums (1.5-2.5×), while chase cards with low PSA 10 populations carry massive premiums (8-15× or more). The threshold question for grading is whether the raw card is worth roughly 4× the grading fee — for Lugia LEGEND at $261.51 raw, grading economics work cleanly. PSA / BGS / CGC are the three main graders; PSA carries the highest market premium for vintage Pokémon, BGS for modern, CGC for anything in between. The grading turnaround time at PSA fluctuates between 30 days (premium service) and 12+ months (bulk service); the bulk service is rarely worth using because the grading fee is small relative to the holding cost of card capital tied up for a year.

Authentication tips before you buy

DP-era HeartGold & SoulSilver cards (2007-2009) and Lv.X chases have low counterfeit rates because the print run is more recent and the holographic pattern is harder to replicate. Tells: (1) Lv.X gold border foil is microtextured — fakes are typically smooth; (2) PSA-graded slabs for $100+ chase cards are the safest acquisition path; (3) standard back blue-line test still applies (genuine DP backs preserve the WotC-era blue line pattern). For any purchase above $200 raw, the rational path is to buy slabbed (PSA/BGS/CGC) and skip the authentication risk entirely — the grading premium is usually less than the counterfeit risk discount.

Explore further

• Open HeartGold & SoulSilver booster packs (free)
• Track your HeartGold & SoulSilver collection
• Browse all 137 PackRip sets